Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

laws =/= amendments. Think of laws as "anything goes, as long as it doesn't go against the constitution". Which includes the process of how congress and the president sign off on a law. There's nothing in the constitution saying that the government can't enforce a minimum wage.

Now if you want a stronger law, or to override the constitution, you perform an even more involved process which includes ratification from 75% of the states. But this is extremely difficult, by design.

>Which one?

In this case, the US code for this is The Fair Labor Standards Act Of 1938, last amended in 2011. But the amendment to this act that increases minimum wage was last amended in 2009.



> laws =/= amendments

Then why did you say "the entire amendment process" in response to my question?

> Think of laws as "anything goes, as long as it doesn't go against the constitution".

No, that's not how it works. The things Congress can legislate about are explicitly enumerated in Article I, Section 8 of the Constitution. Congress can't just pass any law it likes as long as it follows the process given in the Constitution.

> There's nothing in the constitution saying that the government can't enforce a minimum wage.

Again, this is backwards. I'm asking if there is anything in the Constitution that says Congress can enforce a minimum wage. If there isn't, Congress can't do it (unless the Constitution is amended to add that to the list of things Congress can legislate about).

> Now if you want a stronger law, or to override the constitution

There is no such thing as a "stronger law" or "to override the Constitution". The Constitution can be amended, which is what the more difficult process you describe does, but that doesn't "override" it or pass a "stronger law" in spite of it, it amends it.


>why did you say "the entire amendment process" in response to my question?

Because I'm not a lawyer and my main point was "yes, congress can control this stuff"

>The things Congress can legislate about are explicitly enumerated in Article I, Section 8 of the Constitutio

I'm going to guess "setting minimum wage" isn't specifically enumerated in Article I, section 8. But yes, we have federal laws we revise overtime outlining that.

>I'm asking if there is anything in the Constitution that says Congress can enforce a minimum wage.

Probbaly not. But there are mechanisms on how congress can draft laws to enforce a minimum wage. Of course it can be challenged by the SCOTUS, but that's one hell of a hill to die on, even by 2024 standards.

It not adjusting for 15 years is pretty close. Sometimes apathy is the best malice.

>There is no such thing as a "stronger law" or "to override the Constitution". The Constitution can be amended

Did you want to talk about congress passing laws or argue pedantism against the spirit of HN? I'm not a lawyer so my language will not be precise as the centuries and thousands of pages of law talking about this.

My main point was that yes, congress can pass laws that regulate employment. No it doesn't need to be the 28th amendment to take effect. There's no point grilling me on the legalese because that is far outside my purview (and frankly, far outside the scope of a comment on Hacker News. I'm not drafting an entire book try and likely fail to convince someone who is simply prodding instead of giving their own opinions on the matter)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: